Declawing Your Cat: Weighing the Pros and Cons

Cat claws

So, you’re a cat lover. The endless purring, playful moments, and the sense of companionship are a joy to have. But let’s be honest – their little claws can be a bit of a challenge sometimes. This is where declawing comes into the picture. There’s been a lot of talk about it – some good, some not so good. Let’s dive in and explore this contentious topic.

Understanding Declawing

First things first. What is declawing, really? It’s not a fancy manicure for your feline friends, but a surgical procedure. There are two main types – onychectomy, which removes the claw and the small bone it’s attached to, and tendonectomy, which severs the tendon controlling the claw. It’s not something that’s taken lightly, and it’s not even legal everywhere. In fact, it’s outlawed in many parts of Europe and some US cities.

The vets involved in the process have a crucial role. They’re the ones performing the procedure, after all. Their views are mixed, with most veterinary associations advising against it unless absolutely necessary.

What Are the Pros and Cons of Declawing Your Cat?

While we are categorically opposed to declawing cats in the vast majority of situations, there are two sides to every issue. Even in this case, there are pros and cons. Pros include protecting people, household items, and at-risk owners with health issues. It also may prevent having to euthanize or surrender an unruly cat to a shelter. Cons include adverse physical, psychological, and behavioral impacts, as well as ethical considerations.

Let’s explore these in more detail.

Pros of Declawing

Though a contentious topic, there are several arguments made in favor of declawing cats. These advantages predominantly revolve around the protection of humans and their belongings.

Protection of Humans and Household Items

One of the primary benefits proponents of declawing cite is the reduction in scratching-related injuries and prevention of property damage. When cats scratch, whether it’s due to stress, excitement, or simply a natural instinct to mark territory and keep their claws sharp, they can potentially cause harm. This harm extends not only to humans in the form of injuries but also to household items such as furniture, carpets, and curtains that might bear the brunt of their scratching behavior.

Potential Benefits for At-Risk Owners

A particular group of people who may benefit from declawing are those with compromised immune systems or specific health conditions, such as hemophilia. In these cases, even a minor scratch from a cat could potentially lead to serious health complications, including infections. Additionally, older individuals, who are more prone to skin tears and slow-healing wounds, could be at less risk of injury from a declawed cat.

May Prevent Euthanasia or Surrender

In rare and extreme cases, declawing could potentially prevent a cat from being surrendered to a shelter or, worse, euthanized. If an owner has exhausted all other behavioral modification techniques and the cat continues to pose a serious risk due to aggressive scratching, some argue that declawing may be a lesser evil compared to abandonment or euthanasia.

Despite these potential benefits, it’s important to bear in mind that declawing is a significant surgical procedure with its own set of risks, complications, and ethical considerations. This has led to a shift in public and professional attitudes towards this practice. As such, it should not be viewed as a first-line solution but rather a last resort after all other alternatives have been thoroughly explored.

Book Reviews

Cons of Declawing

While declawing may present some benefits, it also brings along several significant drawbacks. These drawbacks range from physical effects to psychological impacts and ethical considerations.

Physical Impact of Declawing a Cat

The foremost argument against declawing is the physical trauma it inflicts on cats. Declawing isn’t simply nail removal. It’s a surgical procedure that involves amputating the last bone of each toe. This can lead to severe postoperative pain and complications like infection or nerve damage. It can even result in long-term physical issues like lameness, back pain, or changes in the way a cat walks.

Psychological and Behavioral Impacts

Beyond physical impacts, declawing can also lead to changes in a cat’s behavior. This surgery removes a cat’s primary means of defense. This can make them feel vulnerable, possibly resulting in increased aggression or fearfulness.

Does Declawing a Cat Change its Personality?

Declawing a cat can potentially lead to changes in its behavior, which may be interpreted as a change in personality. After declawing, cats may become more aggressive or fearful, as their primary means of defense has been removed. They might resort to biting more frequently as a new defense mechanism. Additionally, some cats develop an aversion to using the litter box post-surgery due to the pain associated with scratching in the litter. However, these changes can vary from cat to cat, and not all declawed cats will exhibit these behaviors.

Ethical Considerations

On the ethical front, many argue that declawing is an infringement on a cat’s rights. It’s a procedure that’s carried out for the convenience of the owner, not for the health or well-being of the cat. Because animals can’t consent, removing their claws—a critical part of their natural behavior and defense mechanism—raises questions about animal welfare and ethics.

Winston on the prowl

Dear Joey, there are rumors of something called ‘declawing.’ Don’t be fooled, it’s not a fancy manicure session. It’s more like trying to catch the red dot… but with your toes missing! Imagine, us, regal felines, reduced to toe-less trotting. How could we perfect our dignified strut? Or show that pesky furniture who’s boss? #Don’tTouchMyWolverineClaws #MurderMittensForLife #NoPawNoPeace

Winston

Alternatives to Declawing and Their Efficacy

Critics of declawing point out that there are several effective alternatives. These can address the issues posed by a cat scratching without resorting to surgery. They include training and behavioral modification, using scratching posts and other cat furniture. They also include applying nail caps, and maintaining regular nail trims. Environmental enrichment, such as providing interactive toys or climbing trees, can also help. They do so by giving cats outlets for their natural behavior.

While declawing might seem to offer a quick fix for unwanted scratching behavior, the associated physical, psychological, and ethical downsides make it a less-than-ideal solution. It’s always recommended to explore all alternative methods before considering such a drastic step.

The Veterinarian’s Perspective

Veterinarians, being the professionals entrusted with performing the declawing procedure, hold a pivotal role in this debate.

Circumstances When Declawing a Cat Might Be Recommended

While many veterinarians are shifting away from declawing, some might still recommend it in particular situations. These could include medical necessities, like the presence of a malignant tumor, or situations where the owner’s health is at serious risk from cat scratches. They may also consider it as a last resort when a cat’s aggressive behavior can’t be managed through other means. This can prevent the risk of the cat being surrendered or euthanized.

Role of the Veterinarian in Educating Owners

Vets have a critical role in informing and advising pet owners about the potential physical and behavioral implications of declawing, the alternatives available, and the best practices for dealing with destructive scratching behaviors. They can help owners understand that declawing is not a simple or routine procedure. It’s a significant surgery that can have lasting impacts on a cat’s life.

Changes in Veterinary Policies and Recommendations Over Time

Over time, many veterinary organizations, like the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA), have updated their policies to discourage declawing. The AVMA, for example, now considers declawing a last-resort procedure. Instead, it encourages veterinarians to educate owners about the potential complications and available alternatives. This shift reflects growing recognition within the profession of the significant welfare concerns associated with declawing.

Read the ASPCA’s position statement on declawing cats.

While there might be specific cases where declawing is considered, the general consensus in the veterinary community is that alternatives should be pursued first. Declawing should only be considered when all other options have failed.

Legal and Policy Landscape

The legal and policy views regarding declawing cats have shifted over time. This reflects the changing societal and professional attitudes towards this practice.

Overview of Laws and Regulations about Declawing Worldwide

Globally, laws and regulations around declawing vary. Some countries, like the United Kingdom, Australia, and much of the European Union, have outright banned declawing except for medical reasons. In the United States, there is no federal law regarding declawing. However, some states and cities have implemented bans on the procedure unless it’s necessary for medical purposes. New York State and Denver are just two examples.

Shifts in Policy and Public Sentiment

There’s been a significant shift in public sentiment and policy over the last few years, leaning towards viewing declawing as inhumane and unnecessary. This shift has been influenced by increased awareness about the pain and long-term issues declawing can cause for cats, and the recognition that effective alternatives exist.

Impact of These Laws and Policies on Declawing Rates

The laws and policies banning or discouraging declawing have had a notable impact on declawing rates, with a clear decrease in the areas where such bans are in place. These legal changes, along with increased public awareness and changes in veterinary guidelines, are helping to reduce the prevalence of this procedure and encourage the exploration of alternatives to manage unwanted cat scratching behavior.

The legal and policy landscape around declawing cats is dynamic and is increasingly moving towards limiting or banning the practice. This trend aligns with the shift in public opinion and veterinary guidelines towards recognizing declawing as a significant welfare concern and promoting non-surgical alternatives.

Conclusion

The issue of declawing cats is a complex one, with strong arguments on both sides. But it’s clear that the balance of opinion is shifting, with growing recognition of the physical and psychological impacts on cats and a shift toward exploring alternatives.

Always remember that every cat deserves a happy, healthy life. So before making any decisions, it’s worth having a chat with your vet, doing your own research, and considering all the alternatives to declawing. Remember, informed decision-making is the way to go.

The Painful Truth About Declawing a Cat (And What to Do Instead)

Recent Posts